ArcSight vs. Splunk? Why you might want both

User reviews suggest that rather than choose between the two highly-rated SIEM products, security managers would benefit from having both

boxing gloves
Credit: flickr/Ari Bakker

Two of the most highly-rated software products in the security information and event management (SIEM) market are ArcSight and Splunk, according to online reviews by SIEM software users in the IT Central Station community. But the user reviews show that the two products have such different strengths that, instead of viewing them as direct rivals, users might want both.

ArcSight is HP Enterprise’s family of SIEM software tools for helping businesses protect their data through security analytics. Splunk Inc.’s namesake software is well-known for its log management capabilities.

“[Splunk’s] motto was simple: Throw logs at me and I will provide a Web-based console to search through it intuitively,” says one well-regarded review, written by a manager of enterprise risk consulting. “Splunk is arguably the best search engine for logs out there.”

But this same reviewer says Splunk isn’t a comprehensive SIEM tool. As he put it: “[For] day-to-day security management, monitoring, ticketing etc., [Splunk] has a lot of catching up to do. The ideal scenario will be to use Splunk in the log management layer and use any market-leading SIEM in the correlation, workflow and operational management layer. We have seen several successful implementations where Splunk serves as the log management tool and ArcSight or [IBM’s] QRadar serves as the correlation engine. Best of both worlds!”

Another reviewer – a senior security analyst at a large enterprise – gave ArcSight high marks for scalability and a user-friendly interface, but also called it expensive.

Register now to continue reading the HP ArcSight vs. Splunk product comparison -- with actual user reviews on IT Central Station. There is no obligation or fee. Go now!

This story, "ArcSight vs. Splunk? Why you might want both" was originally published by CSO.

Download the CIO October 2016 Digital Magazine
View Comments
Join the discussion
Be the first to comment on this article. Our Commenting Policies