Microsoft seems ready to give up on Windows phones, if not Windows 10 Mobile

The Surface phone is dead, long live the Surface device?

Acer Liquid Jade Primo

Acer includes a handy case that flips over the front of the phone.

Credit: Mark Hachman

The future of Windows phones...might not be phones?

Rumors and hopes for a category-defining Surface phone were not satisfied at Microsoft's press event last Wednesday. The company didn’t even mention Windows 10 Mobile. With the collective market share of Windows phones stagnant at about 1 percent, customers and partners have to wonder why anyone should bother investing in Microsoft’s mobile strategy.   

In an interview with ZDnet’s Mary Jo Foley, Microsoft executive vice president of Windows and Devices Terry Myerson was asked just that. But instead of committing wholeheartedly to Windows phones—or declaring that product line dead—Myerson tried a different tack: obscurity.

“Technically, there are really two things that are unique about Windows Mobile,” Myerson replied, when asked why Microsoft was, in Foley’s words, “wasting time” upgrading Windows 10 Mobile. “One is cellular connectivity and the other one is the ARM processors that are there.”

“So we’re going to continue to invest in ARM and cellular,” Myerson continued. “And while I’m not saying what type of device, I think we’ll see devices there, Windows devices, that use ARM chips. I think we’ll see devices that have cellular connectivity.”

terry myerson wdg event 2016 2 Blair Hanley Frank

Terry Myerson, the Executive Vice President of Microsoft’s Windows and Devices Group, speaks at a company event in New York City on October 26, 2016.

Devices, not phones

The word Myerson did not use, of course, is “phones,” leading some to speculate that any forthcoming Surface “phone” would instead be a tablet—perhaps an ARM-based tablet, perhaps one with cellular connectivity, but not a phone. 

To recap: Existing Windows phones run on ARM processors from Qualcomm and others, using Windows 10 Mobile. Windows tablets do not. At one point, of course, they did: The original Surface ran on Windows RT, a version of Windows designed for ARM chips. But consumers soundly rejected the Windows RT tablets, and Microsoft reportedly scrapped a smaller “Surface Mini” that may or may not have run Surface RT. 

Instead, Microsoft doubled down on the Surface Pro 3, which went on to become the Windows tablet that helped define Surface and Windows tablets in general. Microsoft encouraged development on what it saw to be a more successful implementation of Windows 10 running on top of ARM: Windows phones. 

Currently we have a pair of Windows 10 flagship phones, each manufactured by Microsoft PC partners: the Acer Liquid Jade Primo and the HP Elite x3. But Microsoft appears ready to flip-flop again. 

Windows Mobile: Part of the Windows 10 train

And why not, Myerson seems to be saying: “When you stop investing in these things, it’s super hard, super, super hard to restart,” Myerson said. “At Microsoft we have a few of those examples where we stopped. Sometimes, when you’re investing into growth. it’s easier, but when you’re investing for technical strategy or things like that, sometimes people can question it—like you’re doing right now.”

Some observers are probably wondering why it’s more difficult for Microsoft to halt development of Windows 10 Mobile than its own Lumia hardware, or why ARM and cellular connectivity are considered to be differentiating features for Microsoft alone—and not, you know,  every phone ever made. Why didn’t Myerson highlight Continuum, Microsoft’s phone-as-PC argument? Or virtualized Win32 apps, as HP’s Passport uses? He’s a straightforward man, though, so it’s most likely he’s simply answering the question in the way Microsoft is now framing the problem. 

Give Myerson a little credit, though. How often are smartphones used for talking? As screen sizes balloon, phones are evolving more into data-driven messaging and computing devices than simple squawk boxes.

No one believes that the cratering of Microsoft’s phone business was all part of some master plan to usher in the next big thing. But the door’s still open for something interesting to emerge from Microsoft’s mobile business. If Myerson’s to be believed,, however, it may not be a phone.

This story, "Microsoft seems ready to give up on Windows phones, if not Windows 10 Mobile" was originally published by PCWorld.

To comment on this article and other CIO content, visit us on Facebook, LinkedIn or Twitter.
Download the CIO October 2016 Digital Magazine
Notice to our Readers
We're now using social media to take your comments and feedback. Learn more about this here.