NEWSLETTERS
 

CIO.com updates, insights and advice on technology, management and your career.

 
 
 
LEADERSHIP
 
CIO Executive Programs
The Leader in Face-to-Face Education for Senior Executives

Offering regional and national programs, CIO (and CSO) events bring together some of the most respected names and thought leaders in information technology and security. Presented by CIOs and other senior level executives, these invitation-only programs offer timely topics and strong networking. Learn More »

 
CIO Executive Council
A Peer-Advisory Service and Professional Association for CIOs

Social Responsibility's Strategic Benefits

December 15, 11:30 AM - 12:30 PM US/Eastern (GMT-5)

Join Ed Granger-Happ, CIO of Save the Children, for a discussion of how creating an organization that is socially responsible improves staffing, retention, leadership development and overall corporate health.

Working With and Communicating to Your Board of Directors

January 13, 2009, 4:00 PM - 5:00 PM US/Eastern (GMT-5)

CIO panelists who will share tips and experiences working with their boards: Twila Day of SYSCO; Jeff O'Hare, West Corp.; Marc West, formerly with H&R Block.

IT's Role in Growing Mid-Market Companies

January 14, 4:00 PM - 5:00 PM ET (GMT-5)

Mid-market Council members will share their companies' stories and challenges in driving or coping with growth. Panelists represent Veterinary Pet Insurance, Medicis Pharmaceutical, and Intrax Cultural Exchange.

More / Register »

Learn more about the CIO Executive Council »



 
 
RESOURCE CENTER
 
 
 
SUBSCRIBE TO CIO
 
Are you involved in setting the direction for your company's IT budget or strategy?

Apply today for a FREE subscription to CIO Magazine!

 
 
 

Advocacy Groups Skeptical of P-to-P Bill of Rights Idea

Two consumer-focused advocacy groups have objected to a P-to-P bill of rights and responsibilities proposed by Comcast and Pando Networks, saying the companies don't have the authority to speak for Internet users.

 

April 16, 2008 — IDG News Service —

Two consumer-focused advocacy groups have objected to a P-to-P bill of rights and responsibilities proposed by Comcast and Pando Networks, saying the companies don't have the authority to speak for Internet users.

Cable modem provider Comcast seems to be trying to lessen criticism of its network management practices after press reports last October showed Comcast was throttling BitTorrent traffic, said Gigi Sohn, president of Public Knowledge, a digital rights group.

The P-to-P (peer-to-peer) bill of rights effort, announced Tuesday, comes after Comcast last month announced an agreement with BitTorrent Inc., a leading user of the BitTorrent P-to-P protocol, with the two companies agreeing to work together to solve network management issues. Pando Networks is a maker of P-to-P software.

"This so-called agreement is simply another way for Comcast to try to evade punishment for its blocking and degrading of peer-to-peer services for its customers," Sohn said in an e-mail. "As with the 'agreement' with BitTorrent, today's announcement is long on rhetoric and short on detail."

Sohn called Comcast's idea for a customer bill of rights "ludicrous."

"Comcast should fix its internal problems with customers being kicked off the Internet service for no good reason, or [who] are disappointed about having programming switched to expensive digital services before it starts pretending to solve the problems of the Internet that it helped to cause," Sohn said.

Marvin Ammori, general counsel of advocacy group Free Press, also questioned the bill of rights.

"Comcast and a company called Pando have declared themselves the arbiters of consumers' rights and responsibilities," he said in an e-mail. "Their announcement gives little information about the arrangement, but Comcast's behavior tells us everything we need to know. For the past year, Comcast has been blocking peer-to-peer applications -- a practice that they continue to this day with no indication of when or if they plan to stop."

Comcast seems to be trying to divert a U.S. Federal Communications Commission inquiry into the traffic blocking, Ammori said. The FCC has scheduled a hearing on network management and net neutrality at Stanford University in California Thursday.

"Comcast's announcement is little more than the fox telling the farmer, 'I'll guard the henhouse, you can go home,'" he said. "And that's all the attention it deserves."

A Comcast spokeswoman didn't immediately respond to a request for comments. A representative of LimeWire, the distributor of a widely used P-to-P software package, also didn't immediately respond to a request for comments on the Comcast proposal.

But an FCC spokesman said Wednesday the Comcast/Pando idea deserves to be considered. The FCC has invited representatives of the two companies to speak at the Thursday hearing, said spokesman Robert Kenny.

Loading...
 
 
IT Jobs
 
 
 
ABCs
 

Just the basics, please. Sometimes we all need a refresher or we need to make sure our team and our colleagues are all on the same page.

Over 25 tutorials on everything from business intelligence to virtualization.

 
 
FEATURED SPONSORS
 
 
 
SPONSORED LINKS
 

Virtualization Benchmark and TCO Analysis-Read Now

White Paper: Scaling Down HPC for Smaller Organizations

White Paper: Never Enough Compute Power?

Microsoft Windows Vista Cost and Benefit Estimator

White Paper: Efficient Desktop Application Management

White Paper: Take your Call Center to the Next Level

Is Your WLAN Helping You Comply with Security Guidelines of the PCI Standard?

White Paper: Improve Employee Efficiency and Reduce Telecom Costs

White Paper: Green Issues for Networking

New IDG Survey Results on Data Center Automation

Operational Excellence Is Key to Maximizing IT Investments

The Right and Wrong Master Data Management Strategies to Start Small and Grow Big

Find out how to manage virtualization's risks and reap the rewards.

Conquer the realities of managing virtualization

Remote Infrastructure Management - What Your Peers are Thinking

Complementary BI: The New Approach to Business Intelligence

Unified Communications & Collaboration: Game-Changing Business Results

The ECM Paradox: Extending Local Flexibility to Strengthen Central Control

Customer Insight Yields Sales, Marketing Gains

Efficient by design: Watch this flash demo of the Quad-Core AMD Opteron Processor

HP and Oracle deploy unbreakable computing infrastructure at Replacements, Ltd.

File Integrity Monitoring: Prove compliance and secure your IT environments

Affordable technology-no compromise. HP server solutions

SOA Educational Library at the TIBCO SOA Resource Center

CIO Viewpoints: Migrating to Exchange 2007

Server Virtualization Benchmark Results

Learn to Leverage Maximum Computing Power

Windows Vista: Essential Benefits and Deployment Strategies

Best Practices: Safe and Secure Hardware Asset Recovery

White Paper: Migrating to Windows Vista and Microsoft Office 2007 Together

White Paper: Enabling Next Generation IP Communications

White Paper: A Cohesive Network Security Approach

Why Your Firewall, VPN, and IEEE Aren't Enough to Protect Your Network

Dramatically boost network capacity and speed-up to 600 Mbps

White Paper: The Roadmap to Data Center Automation

Learn how companies are changing how they reach out to their most profitable customers.

Get help navigating the management challenges of virtualization.

Narrow the gap between virtualization's benefits and the management risks.

Cash in on the promise of virtualization

Webcast - "Into the Wild: Managing Laptops Outside the Office"

Mobility is Growing: Survey Shows Why CIOs are Concerned

Learn what it takes to build a holistic digital collaboration platform

Make Hidden Trends, Inter-Relationships and Influences Visible.

Improve delivery of product information to customers.

Renowned Engineering Institution Chooses AMD Processor-Based Servers

Corral, configure and control all your mischievous machinery with a Lantronix device server

Spend less. Get hosted UC. Get cash back. It's easy under a Cypress

Predict the future with HP Insight Power Manager

Log onto Hitachi True Stories, films inspired by the next great achievement

Earn PROFESSIONAL DOCTORATE Part-Time, Online at Syracuse University's iSchool