IT DRILLDOWN
 
NEWSLETTERS
 

CIO.com updates, insights and advice on technology, management and your career.

 Advice and Opinion

 CIO Consumer IT

 CIO Leader

 CIO Enterprise

 CIO Insider

 

RSS Feeds »

 
 
LEADERSHIP
 

CIO Executive Programs

The Leader in Face-to-Face Education for Senior Executives

Offering regional and national programs, CIO (and CSO) events bring together some of the most respected names and thought leaders in information technology and security. Presented by CIOs and other senior level executives, these invitation-only programs offer timely topics and strong networking. Learn More »

 

CIO Executive Council

Public Teleconferences

Join CIO Executive Council members and participate in the following live teleconferences:

* Planning for Succession:
Models for IT Leadership Development, June 23
* Youth in IT: How CIOs Can Engage the Next Generation
June 10
* Change Leadership at General Growth Properties: A
Pathways Leadership Development Seminar, June 25

More / Register »

Learn more about the CIO Executive Council »



 
 
RESOURCE CENTER
 
 
 
SUBSCRIBE TO CIO
 

Are you involved in setting the direction for your company's IT budget or strategy?


Apply today for a FREE subscription to CIO Magazine!

Subscription Services »

Reprints »

 
 

Feature

 

Oracle v. SAP Legal Fight Gets Messier, Raises Tough Questions About Third-Party Maintenance

Details from new court documents show potential legal quagmires for both third-party maintenance and support providers and their customers. Will the case rock the whole third-party maintenance business? No, say TomorrowNow's rivals.
 

April 25, 2008CIO — In mid-April, more details emerged from new court documents filed by Oracle and SAP in their year-long legal dispute regarding allegations that SAP illegally accessed Oracle's customer support systems.

At the center of the furor: Did SAP's subsidiary, TomorrowNow, a provider of third-party maintenance support for Oracle's stable of business applications, engage in "systematic, illegal access to—and taking from—Oracle's computerized customer support systems," as Oracle's 2007 lawsuit alleges.

Oracle claims that as a result, "SAP has compiled an illegal library of Oracle's copyrighted software code and other materials," as the suit states. (See "SAP's Purchase and Attempt to Sell Off TomorrowNow" for an in-depth account of the TomorrowNow saga.)

Even though SAP has put TomorrowNow on the block, the case has not stood still. One of the latest court documents filed is what's called a "Joint Case Management Conference Statement," filed in advance of the April 24 conference between the two parties in U.S. District Court in San Francisco. (At the conference, Judge Phyllis J. Hamilton reviewed the discovery process and deposition limits and confirmed that the schedule for alternative dispute resolution would remain in place.)

In the filing, Oracle sought to amend its complaint and add some new charges against SAP, including this claim: "SAP AG and SAP America knew—at executive levels—of the likely illegality of TomorrowNow's business model from the time of their acquisition of TomorrowNow and, for business reasons, failed to change it."

Dirty and Difficult Questions

Legalese aside, Oracle v. SAP is messy and complicated. The Joint CMC statement contains 30 pages of incendiary allegations by both parties, he-said-she-said barbs and frank admissions by SAP and Oracle hinting at just how hard it is for each side to make its case. For example, the discovery process, in which both parties gather evidence (in this case from computer systems) and interview people on both sides, has already become a massive, intricate and costly legal proceeding.

"To date, the discovery in this case has involved immense computer records, including terabytes of data, that require weeks to simply copy, not to mention produce, review and digest," notes Oracle's defense team. "This case also involves potentially hundreds of third parties, thousands of computer software environments, and tens of thousands of distinct downloads of Oracle Software and Support Materials⬦.The subjects are vast and complicated, including the development, maintenance and use of these thousands of customer support environments by defendants—none of which has yet been produced because the physical size of these electronic records is so great."

SAP counters that "Oracle started this case without ever raising its concerns with SAP, apparently preferring instead to use the burden of tens of millions of dollars of discovery expense and the attendant distraction to aid its ongoing competition with SAP."

 
 
 
 
 
 
Loading...
 
 
ABCs
 

How To Do Nearly Anything

Just the basics, please. Sometimes we all need a refresher or we need to make sure our team and our colleagues are all on the same page.

Over 25 tutorials on everything from business intelligence to virtualization.

 
 
FEATURED SPONSORS
 
 
 
SPONSORED LINKS
 

White Paper: Learn how to succeed with BPM

Increase conversions on your site with the help of EV SSL.

Performance Brief: Mobile Application Acceleration

Nothing Short of Revolutionary: Four Steps toward More Effective Enterprise Finance

White Paper: Unlocking the Potential of B2B

Shift your ERP investments into high gear and join the leaders!

Evolve your data center on proven technology. The Brocade DCX.

Taking Control of Software Licensing

Simple, Economical Server Virtualization for Any Size Company

Learn about B2B integration for Companies of All Sizes

Integration as a Service Webcast: Are you connected?

WAN Optimization for mobile users is critical to your business success.

Case Study: 24 Hour Fitness turned to SEPATON

White Paper: HP Application Modernization Services

Establishing a Strategy for Global Distributed Development

Oracle Database 11g: Advances in Compression, Real Application Testing and Data Guard

InfoWorld Test Center on Oracle Active Data Guard

This white paper highlights best-of-breed solutions being built on the Microsoft platform

A Must Read on Data Protection Strategies!

Read the FREE Forrester study "Optimizing Users and Applications in a Mobile World"

Fujitsu Case Study - Thomson Learning

State of the Portal Market 2007: Portals and the Power of Participation

Write an RFP for Master Data Management: 10 Common Mistakes to Avoid

Building Compliance and Security into an Application Delivery Framework

Keys to a smooth and successful Office 2007 rollout, before, during and after!

BPM Done Right: 15 Ways to Succeed Where Others have Failed

How Office 2007 Exposed Bill Gates

Citrix XenServer FREE trial

TDWI Research report clears confusion about automating data governance

Tuning ERP and the Supply Chain for Profitable Growth

IDC VP Carl Olofson Reviews Technology Advances and How to Handle Reporting and Querying

Mitigating Risk with Security Assessments

White Paper: IDC Analysts Discuss Open Text

Case Study: Customer Integration Wins at Invitrogen

Internet's Largest Book Retailer Scores Big with B2B Customers

Riverbed RiOS 4.0: Raising the Bar in Wide Area Data Services

Business Value of Performance IDC Whitepaper

BPM At The Crossroads Webcast" Tackling the "Hard Issues" to Drive Success

Top 10 Questions to Ask when Choosing a Secure File Transfer Solution

InfoWorld Test Center on Oracle Real Application Testing

Oracle Real Application Testing with Oracle Database 11g

An Executive Guide to Understanding Hosted and Managed Messaging

BEA & Forrester Webcast: "The Enterprise 2.0 Workplace." Register Now!

LIVE Webcast - The Mainframe is Dead...Long Live the Mainframe?

White Paper: Learn how wide-area data services accelerate information across wide-area networks

Learn about the Power of Pen Computing

Webcast: Optimizing Wide-Area Data Services

Putting Windows Server and Citrix to Work in the Enterprise

Getting Off on the Right Foot: Avoiding Common Master Data Management False Starts

The Case and Criteria for Combining Application Acceleration and Security