Study: Comcast, Cox Slowing P2P Traffic Around the Clock

By Grant Gross

Thu, May 15, 2008 — IDG News Service —

U.S. cable broadband providers Comcast and Cox Communications are slowing BitTorrent traffic at all times of the day, not just during peak traffic, according to a new study by a German computer research group.

Comcast has insisted that it uses network management techniques to slow some peer-to-peer traffic during times of peak congestion, but the study from the Max Planck Institute for Software Systems suggests that Comcast and Cox are slowing BitTorrent traffic "independent of the time of day."

The study, using more than 8,000 nodes worldwide to test for BitTorrent blocking, found that Comcast was interrupting at least 30 percent of BitTorrent upload attempts around the clock. At noon, Comcast was interfering with more than 80 percent of BitTorrent traffic, but it was also slowing more than 60 percent of BitTorrent traffic at other times, including midnight, 3 a.m. and 8 p.m. Eastern Time in the U.S., the time zone where Comcast is based, according to tests run by users of the institute's Glasnost network testing tool.

Cox was interfering with 100 percent of the BitTorrent traffic at 1 a.m., 4 a.m. and 5 a.m., also Eastern Time, according to the tests.

Comcast downplayed the results. P-to-p traffic makes up 50 percent to 90 percent of a network's traffic, and BitTorrent users can be on the network at any time, said Comcast spokeswoman Sena Fitzmaurice. That means network congestion from BitTorrent doesn't just happen in the middle of the day, she added.

"P-to-p traffic doesn't necessarily follow normal traffic flows," Fitzmaurice said.

The Internet users who participated in the study may not be representative of Internet users overall, she added. The users who run the Glasnost tests may be "heavy users of p-to-p," Fitzmaurice said.

Cox did not have an immediate comment on the study.

Comcast issued a statement repeating its earlier position that it "does not, has not, and will not block any Web sites or online applications," including BitTorrent.

"We have acknowledged that we manage peer-to-peer traffic in a limited manner to minimize network congestion," Comcast's statement continued. "While we believe our current network management approach was a reasonable choice, we are now working with a variety of companies including BitTorrent [to] move to a protocol-agnostic network management technique."

Comcast announced in March that it would work with the company named BitTorrent to come up with new network management techniques.

The Max Planck Institute's study seems to confirm testimony by U.S. Federal Communications Commission Chairman Kevin Martin, who told U.S. lawmakers in April that Comcast's interference with BitTorrent traffic appeared to be widespread.

Loading...
Network MarketSpace
White Papers
The Challenge of a Demanding Network Infrastructure
Today's data centers are expanding as demand for data and storage continues to grow exponentially. Learn more »
Reduce Infrastructure and Administrative Costs
The Brocade® FastIron® CX Series of switches provides new levels of performance. Learn more »
A New Generation of Application Delivery Controllers (ADCs)
Learn more about Brocade® ServerIron® intelligent application delivery and traffic management solutions. Learn more »
Want to Offer a Superior User Experience?
Control a "boundary-less" enterprise with scalable solutions. Learn more »
Realize Potential Without Increasing Your Risk
Combining Brocade's high-performance infrastructure and McAfee's Web gateway solution ensures trusted environments. Learn more »
Brocade and Imperva: Providing Best-of-Breed Products
Web applications have become the backbone of business in nearly every segment of the economy. Learn more »
 
SPONSORED LINKS
 

Maximizing the Business Value of the PC Infrastructure

Enterprise PBX Comparison Guide

Getting Value from Outdated Networking Equipment

Seven Ways ITIL Can Help You in an Economic Downturn

Data Loss Prevention: A Better Way to Approach Security

Learn how to managing client systems in the enterprise.

Cloud Computing: Read about VMware's compelling vision & set of products

Top-line Performance that's Bottom-line Efficient

Accenture: Outsourcing for uncertain times. Click to learn more.

White Paper: 8 Key Ingredients to Building an Internal Cloud

Read about virtualization and consolidation effort best practices

Building the Virtualized Enterprise with VMware Infrastructure

Top 10 Business and IT Drivers for the Wealth Management Sector

Bottom-Line Benefits of Virtualization

White Paper: The Building Blocks for Cloud Computing

Oracle's Application Grid Technical Demo

Next-Generation Application Servers and Infrastructure

Application Infrastructure at Enterprise Organizations

Achieving Business Agility with Application Grid

Learn about The Information Technology Infrastructure Library.

Achieving Pervasive Performance Management

Automating the Generation and Secure Distribution of Excel Reports

Reduce risk, gain agility. See how Progress can help your business.

Improve ROI, lower TCO and reduce energy consumption.

Introducing the new HP ProLiant G6 server family

Enterprise PBX Buyer's Guide

Secondary Market Primer: Your Network at Half Price

Taking the Service Desk to the Next Level

Why Data Loss is Increasing--and What You Can Do About It

Communications and Collaboration Needs at Business Organizations

Using Open Source to Deploy Web Applications

Mid-Sized Company CIO Community: infoBOOM!

Accenture IT Consulting: Logical meets technological. More . . .

Stop Application Fraud at the Source with Device Reputation

Learn about the VMware vSphere (TM) & Intel (R) Xeon (R) Processor 5500 Series

Learn how a virtualized enterprise can help your company reduce costs

Why Isn't Server Virtualization Saving Us More?

8 Key Ingredients to Building an Internal Cloud

Data Center Optimization: Three Key Strategies

A CIO Executive Guide: Cloud Computing Looms Big on the Horizon

Oracle WebLogic Server Technical Demo

Data Grids and Service-Oriented Architecture

Achieving the Impossible: Unlimited Application Scalability

A Middleware Foundation for Application Grid

Tips for successful virtualization management.

Smart Decisions: The Role of Key Performance Indicators

Gartner Shares Predictions for 2009

64-page prescriptive guide to security, compliance, and IT operations.

Get Google Enterprise Search for your business information.

Accenture IT Consulting: Enabling high performance. More...

 
 
RESOURCE CENTER