Virtualization Advisor

Expert analysis and advice on server virtualization technologies, deployments and management.

RSS
All Posts | RSS

Our bloggers: Kevin Fogarty is a veteran technology journalist and analyst who has previously worked for Computerworld, Baseline, eWeek, and Illuminata. Virtualization expert Edward L. Haletky is the author of "VMWare ESX Server in the Enterprise: Planning and Securing Virtualization Servers", Pearson Education (2008) and runs his own firm, AstroArch Consulting. Laurianne McLaughlin serves as technology editor for CIO, focusing on virtualization as a primary area of coverage.

Tue, July 08, 2008

VMware's ESX Hardening Guideline Falls Far Short of 'Secure'

By Edward L. Haletky

Keywords: Virtual server, virtual security, VMware security guide

As I've discussed in previous blogs on security for virtual environments, there is a severe lack of comprehensive guidance available on how to secure virtual servers and the parts of an IT infrastructure they touch.

Non-vendor organizations offer some help; more specific documentation is available from the vendors themselves. Even that guidance is somewhat lacking, however.

VMware has several white papers on security, most notable the VI3 Security Hardening guideline and DMZ Virtualization With VI3.

The DMZ paper is useful. But the VI3 Hardening Guideline, which is the place most virtual server managers would start to find security information, falls seriously short of the goal of helping to harden an entire virtual infrastructure or even a single VMware ESX system.

The VI3 Hardening Guideline suffers from the same issues I described in my blog on the CISecurity Benchmark. It gives lip service to the hardening of virtual machines, but most of the discussion is on how to use the remote logging service, and isolate the VM Network.

It does not cover the ability of a virtual machine to isolate itself and the data it protects—abilities with the potential to disallow information leakage to someone who has access to the virtual infrastructure but not to the specific VM being protected.

The discussion on the service console reads like a Linux hardening guideline but is already missing many of the items mentioned in the CISecurity Benchmark.

It further states you should only use the VI Client to access your host (physical) systems. As we all know, this is not only impossible, it fails to address the split-brain authentication and authorization problem of a system with three three separate login facilities.

Furthermore it says you should use a directory service like Active Directory but does not discuss how to structure permissions to disable access to critical files which could contain the root password.

Access to root passwords is possible only if configuration files hold the wrong permissions. While the guide does recommend that IT managers monitor the configuration files to make sure the correct permissions have been granted and have not been changed, it doesn't say what the permissions should be in the first place.

The default setup is, not surprisingly, inadequate. It allows for quite a bit of information leakage.

The guide does start to discuss security of items outside the service console including storage, and networking.

However, the storage discussions focus only on iSCSI, and are misleading even then.

For iSCSI to work within VI3, the service console has to be involved in some way. Hence the statement in the white paper that it's necessary to completely isolate an iSCSI network is incorrect. It cannot be 100% isolated.

Loading...
Virtualization Vendor Matrix

Find out what vendors offer the products you need.

View the Vendor Matrix »
Virtualization ABCs

Get up to speed on virtualization.

Learn More »
Virtualization MarketSpace
MarketSpace White Papers
HP and VMware: Virtualization to consolidate server resources for maximum efficiency
Virtualization enables proven cost savings and efficiencies. Now you can tap that power by consolidating multiple applications and heterogeneous operating systems on a single server... Learn more »
Gartner Paper: U.S. Data Centers
According to Gartner, the majority of existing US datacenters have not been designed to handle future energy demands. Strategic decisions, including the implementation of virtualization, must be made quickly... Learn more »
Gartner Paper: How IT Management Can "Green" the Data Center
Datacenters consume large amounts of energy, so it is imperative that IT management establishes energy efficiency goals and an integrated approach to energy-saving initiatives... Learn more »
 
SPONSORED LINKS
 

Consolidation: Just the Starting Point for Virtualization

Getting in Compliance with Government Data Regulations

Forrester Total Economic Impact (TEI) report: Save Millions in Fraud Losses.

The Benefits of Data Deduplication for Data Protection in the Enterprise

File Integrity Monitoring: Secure Your Virtual & Physical IT Environments

How the Mac is Becoming an IT Standard in the Enterprise

Storage Efficiency: The Key to Green Storage Operation

Oracle Database 11g: Real Application Testing & Manageability

Reap the Benefits of Unified Communications

Efficient by design: Watch this flash demo of the Quad-Core AMD Opteron Processor

HP and Oracle deploy unbreakable computing infrastructure at Replacements, Ltd.

Optimizing Infrastructure Control

Effective Security with a Continuous Approach to ISO 27001 Compliance

Best Practices for Providing Secure and Cost-Effective Remote Access

How Does Your IT Help Desk Measure Up?

White Paper: Businesses Thrive by Unifying Business Communications

Sheriff's Office Uses PocketCop to Access Police Databases from BlackBerry® Smartphones

The BlackBerry Solution Adds Significant Benefit to Toshiba

Network Immunity Manager Video

Spam-proof your business with Google's hosted security solutions

Global Crossing is the most viable alternative for voice, video and data

Plan better, manage better

Dell Latitude: Battery life up to 19 hours. Learn more

Video: 21st Century Networking for a 12th Century Castle

Speed, agility, flexibility - The HP BladeSystem c-Class

The Latest Advancements in SSL Technology

How to Offer the Strongest SSL Encryption

Destination: Intelligent Data Center Automation

Build up or Tear down? See how UC makes sense with Nortel. Calculate your UC ROI

Protecting Data in a Highly Networked World

Maximizing Site Visitor Trust Using Extended Validation SSL

Standalone Server vs. Open Source Toolkits

Getting Off on the Right Foot: Avoiding Common Master Data Management False Starts

The Challenge of Network Access Control -- Is a Managed Service the Answer?

Renowned Engineering Institution Chooses AMD Processor-Based Servers

New research validates telepresence solutions.

Configuration Assessment: Choosing the Right Solution

They Can't Steal What You Don't Have: Smart Security Choices for Mobile Workers

How to Calculate the ROI of Remote Support

31 Best Practices for the Service Desk

Unified Communications Software: The Death of VoIP?

Heinz Uses a Wireless, Automated, Auditing process on BlackBerry® devices

Write an RFP for Master Data Management: 10 Common Mistakes to Avoid

HP Puts Its Disaster-tolerant Capabilities to the Test

Compuware.com - See how we make IT rock around the world

CA delivers deeper insight into your assets, resources, projects & services so you can make more informed IT decisions

Discover PMI's credentials and career path tools

SOA Educational Library at the TIBCO SOA Resource Center

TDWI Report shows strong validation for investing in predictive analytics

Learn about the software-based VoIP solution from Microsoft

 
 
RESOURCE CENTER