Smartphone Smackdown: Palm Treo Pro and HP iPaq 910c Business Messenger

The newest Palm Treo and HP iPaq unlocked phones aim to take a bite out of the business phone market. But do they have the chops to do so?

By Yardena Arar

CONNECTIONS
Palm
HP
Google
Fri, August 29, 2008PC World In the world of smart phones, while Apple's TV ads insist that the iPhone 3G "works great with work" and BlackBerry fans eagerly await RIM's BlackBerry Bold, new Windows Mobile 6.1 handsets offer alternative products to corporate users who are willing to pay top dollar for a high-end smart phone with advanced features. I looked at shipping versions of two newcomers, HP's iPaq 910c Business Messenger and Palm's Treo Pro.

Both are being sold unlocked, meaning that at launch you won't get them at a carrier's site; rather, you can use them on any GSM carrier worldwide simply by inserting that carrier's SIM card. This flexibility is great for frequent travelers--you're not tied to a carrier or a long-term plan, and you can pop in an overseas carrier's SIM card to keep costs down (if you don't mind changing your phone number). But it also means you don't get the type of carrier subsidy that has made the iPhone 3G so affordable. The Palm Treo Pro debuts at $549, and HP's iPaq 910c Business Messenger costs $499.

Two Phones, Many Similarities

Both of these glossy black, candy-bar handsets sport hardware QWERTY keyboards. Both support just about all of the wireless connectivity a person could currently ask for: Wi-Fi, GPS, quad-band (world) voice, and high-speed HSDPA/UMTS data networks (in the United States, AT&T Wireless is the only nationwide carrier to support this GSM-family high-speed technology).

Viewed side-by-side, the Palm is clearly the smaller and lighter of the two: The manufacturer's specs peg it at 2.4 inches by 4.5 inches by 0.5 inch and 4.7 ounces compared to the iPaq's 2.5 inches by 4.5 inches by 0.6 inch and 5.4 ounces. Neither has an exceptionally generous amount of built-in storage: Both provide 128MB of RAM for running apps and 256MB of flash ROM, most of which will be occupied by operating-system and application files.

Both phones also provide a micro-SD Card slot that lets users add the storage room for images, music, documents, applications, and so on; here, however, Palm outclasses HP by supporting cards with up to 32GB of capacity, while HP supports up to 4GB. Both phones also come with USB syncing cables; Palm's slides into an AC adapter for recharging, while HP's adapter has its own cable.

Each of the phones has a touch screen--unlike RIM's BlackBerrys, which have yet to incorporate such a feature. The Palm's touch screen is a transflective 320-by-320-pixel display, while the HP's is a transmissive 320-by-240-pixel display--but both look crisp and bright. Conveniently, each phone offers multiple navigation options, and each includes a stylus (stored within the unit) and a central navigation touchpad. HP in particular makes single-handed operation exceptionally easy by providing a scroll wheel and an OK button on the right side of the iPaq. Palm, meanwhile, has a handy dedicated button on the right side for turning Wi-Fi off and on.

Palm

Loading...
Mobile MarketSpace
Tokenless Two-Factor Authentication In Action
Learn how this technology works, how to implement it, and compare it to other two-factor authentication solutions available on the market today. Learn more »
Mobile Security Landscape
This paper examines the current mobile security landscape, including myths surrounding the risks and threats, and how organizations can establish a solid mobile security strategy. Learn more »
Research: Microsoft Mobile Solutions
This paper compares the Research In Motion BlackBerry solution with the Microsoft(R) mobile solution by analyzing features of the user experience and the administrator experience. Learn more »
Five-Step Mobility Management Plan
This complimentary Aberdeen report details how best-in-class companies are using a 5-Step Mobility Management approach to take control of their burgeoning mobile infrastructures. A must read for IT executives looking to cut mobility TCO and support costs, reduce security risks and increase mobile user productivity Learn more »
Getting Started with LogMeIn Rescue
In this brief demo, you will see LogMeIn Rescue's key features and discover how they can help you support more users on PCs, Macs and smartphones, and solve more issues than ever before. Learn more »
Legacy Tools: Not Built for the Helpdesk
This paper explores the challenges of supporting this workforce with legacy tools such as RDP" and VNC" and identifies best practices that you can use to choose helpdesk tools. Learn more »
IT Supporting a Decentralized Organization
Learn the 5 best practices for remote IT support. Learn more »
It Pays to Provide High-Quality Support
Ceridian is a global organization that provides HR and payroll services to Fortune 500 businesses. See how Ceridian deployed remote IT support to reduce call center volume and improve customer support. Learn more »
 
SPONSORED LINKS
 

Mobile Security: The Essential Ingredient for Today's Enterprise

White Paper: Legacy Tools: Not Built for the Helpdesk

Learn how to maximize the mobile web opportunity

See how AT&T can help protect your network.

Webcast: Unleashing the Power of Customer Data

White Paper: Improve Agility with Operational Responsiveness

Taking a Seat at the Executive Table: The Reality of Virtualization

White Paper: Next Generation Remote Infrastructure Management

Keeping Your Members Safe from Online Scams and Predators

The Total Economic Impact of Network Security Intrusion Prevention

Join us at the US-Brazil IT-BPO Summit, on November 10th in New York.

Increase UPS efficiency without sacrificing protection.

Learn how advanced forecasting tools can deliver significant business results for global corporations.

Lower IT Costs with Oracle Database 11g Release 2

Ready to virtualize tier one applications? Check your virtualization maturity.

Seven Ways ITIL Can Help You in an Economic Downturn

Tips for successful virtualization management.

Unified Communications: Thoughts, Strategies and Predictions. Join the discussion

Read the RSA report: Security for Business Innovation

Webcast: Looking to the Cloud for Email and Collaboration Services

64-page prescriptive guide to security, compliance, and IT operations.

Keep your IT expertise up to date. Join the Intel Premier IT Professionals.

A Clear View Toward Virtualization

Virtualization Technology as a Business Solution

The rules of infrastructure management just changed.

White Paper: 5 Best Practices for Smartphone Support

Five-Step Mobility Management Plan

White Paper: Visibility and the New Normal of Mobile Work

White Paper: 4 Customer Service Myths

White Paper: Managed Security for a Not-So-Secure World

Global Research: CIOs Weigh In On Virtualization

5 Key Virtualization Management Challenges

Secure Email and Web-Based Communication from Evolving Attacks

WagerWorks Takes Fraudsters Out of the Game using iovation

Seven Design Requirements for Web 2.0 Threat Protection

Generation Remote Infrastructure Management - Changing the Paradigm

Cloud-Based Email Management: Opinion Shifts In Favor

eBook: How Can You Make Your People Productive Anywhere?

Achieving Business Agility with Application Grid

Taking the Service Desk to the Next Level

Learn about The Information Technology Infrastructure Library.

Top Five CIO Challenges

Streamline IT Costs. Boost Performance with WAN Optimization.

Want to know how you can maximize employee productivity?

Build your 1st app FREE with Force.com

TDWI checklist helps define data readiness for analytics. Download report.

A new fleet of PCs with a total ROI in 10 months. Find your ROI.

eZine: A Roadmap to Reducing IT Complexity

Reduce risk, gain agility. See how Progress can help your business.

Virtualization Technology as a Business Solution

 
 
RESOURCE CENTER