Are Sealed-in Laptop Batteries a Good Idea?
When Apple introduced its new MacBooks recently, it touted a doubled battery life -- but noted that the laptops' batteries were sealed into the case, not user-swappable as is the norm on laptops. What are the pros and cons of this approach?
Mon, June 29, 2009
InfoWorld — When Apple introduced its new MacBooks recently, it touted a doubled battery life -- but noted that the laptops' batteries were sealed into the case, not user-swappable as is the norm on laptops.
The MacBook Air and Dell's Adamo knock-off of it also use sealed-in batteries, but the MacBook Pros are the first mainstream laptops to take this leap. Given Apple's influence on PC makers, sealed batteries may become more prevalent. Is that such a good idea?
[ See how long your battery lasts with InfoWorld's battery life calculator. | InfoWorld debunks 10 power-saving myths. ]
At first blush, the idea of a non-removable battery in a laptop seems ill advised. After all, batteries are absolutely key to laptops, and everyone has had a laptop with a battery that just won't hold a charge, requiring you to be no more than five feet from an outlet. In those cases, it's simple to buy a new battery and install it in a few seconds.
Why sealed-in batteries trouble users and IT The most common complaint about having a sealed-in battery revolves around being on a long-distance flight or waiting in an airport lobby where no power plugs are available, where even a five-hour battery may not be enough to get you through. In those cases, having a spare battery in your bag can mean the difference between finishing the report you're writing (or the movie you're watching) and having to entertain yourself with the final 30 minutes of "Bride Wars" on an off-color overhead screen.
There's also the case of those who work in remote locations -- such as war zones -- where wired power may not be readily available. In extreme cases, the ability to swap batteries there can mean life and death.
More prosaically, sealed-in batteries create a hassle when a battery fails, as the laptop must be returned to the vendor, causing significant delays to users and more overhead for IT to manage. Likewise, some batteries can swell over time, and if the battery is fixed into the computer, it may damage sensitive parts.
So why seal batteries in at all? Given the potential problems, why would vendors seal in batteries?
Simply put, if a laptop manufacturer doesn't have to worry about a removable battery compartment, the design of a laptop is simpler. Without the inset for the battery, the connectors, the catches, the support frame, and so on, a battery can take on different physical forms and be larger than their removable counterparts. That means there's less need to design around the battery's shape and location.
