Deathmatch: Palm Pre Vs. IPhone
There's been one promised iPhone killer after another - the Google Android-based G1, the RIM BlackBerry Storm, the yet-to-ship, years-delayed Windows Mobile 7 - but none has given it worthwhile competition to date. Now Palm has its Pre, a device that looks to be a serious contender for the best next-gen mobile device crown.
Where the iPhone wins The iPhone is a better device for business users, especially those in enterprise environments. Its ability to send calendar invites is one of those little things that make all the difference when you’re doing business on the road. And the iPhone has a bunch of better-thought-out capabilities. Plus, its management and security capabilities are much stronger than the Pre’s if you use the free iPhone Configuration Utility.
The iPhone’s device search is more capable, and its copy-and-paste functionality is both easier to use and more broadly usable. And the iPhone has a major leg up in the wealth of apps available for it.
The overall winner is ... The Pre is a surprisingly strong competitor to the groundbreaking iPhone. RIM’s efforts to compete with the iPhone have been uninspiring; the Google Android platform turned out to be a weak competitor, too wrapped up in Google’s offerings to the exclusion of the business world; and Microsoft has been AWOL.
For business users, the iPhone wins InfoWorld’s mobile deathmatch, but it was no knockout fight. Individual users will have a tougher decision to make and likely end up choosing based on device and UI aesthetics (Galen prefers the iPhone still, but Brandon is quite happy that he chose the Pre) and the appeal (or not) of the communication collaboration the Pre enables but the iPhone does not.
A year ago, the Pre could have derailed the iPhone. Today, the iPhone has moved enough ahead to stay in front. But the Pre is close on its heels, and its multitasking strength is what could ultimately let it blow past the iPhone in a next iteration.
Related articlesMobile deathmatch: Palm Pre vs. iPhone, side by sideWhich mobile device can do the most for you? See what each can do -- or not -- in this slideshow comparisonDeathmatch rematch: BlackBerry versus iPhone 3.0Does the newest iPhone OS eliminate the few advantages the BlackBerry Bold had in our original deathmatch comparison?Deathmatch: BlackBerry versus iPhoneIt’s time for us to bury the BlackBerry and move on to modern mobile -- even for e-mailMobile deathmatch rematch: BlackBerry vs. iPhone 3.0, side by sideHow much more than a phone can these devices be? See what each can do -- or not -- in this comparisonHow much work can you do on an iPhone?The laptop-free promise of today’s next-gen mobile devices is put to the test. Can the iPhone 3G deliver?How much work can you do on a BlackBerry?The laptop-free promise of today’s next-gen mobile devices is put to the test. Can BlackBerry Bold deliver?InfoWorld's Deep Dive Report: Mobile 2.0 TechFind out how the new crop of next-gen mobile devices perform and how to make the most of them in this 20-page PDF guide from InfoWorld's editors and contributors.21 apps Apple doesn't want on your iPhoneWorthwhile productivity apps you won't find at the App StoreCan you manage an iPhone like a BlackBerry?Apple's iPhone 3.0 OS and iPhone Configuration Utility 2.0 extend the iPhone's enterprise-class management and security features. The InfoWorld Test Center sees how far they really goFirst look: iPhone 3G S is evolution in actionThe iPhone 3G S is less revolutionary than its predecessors, but is still moving in the right directioniPhone 3.0: An InfoWorld guided tourApple's forthcoming update fills a number of important holes for users; here's a sneak peek at the key new featuresiPhone applications get down to businessInfoWorld picks the best iPhone apps for connecting with business systems and boosting mobile productivityA developer's-eye view of smartphone platformsAs smartphones evolve into serious computers, the worlds of iPhone, Android, BlackBerry, Nokia Symbian, Palm, and Windows Mobile offer developers new possibilities. Which world should you choose?The cross-platform option: Web apps for smartphonesTailoring a Web application for iPhone, BlackBerry, and other top devices has many advantages over costly native development, and new techniques and approaches are closing the functionality gapiPhone jailbreaking still going strongDespite Apple's formal opposition and upcoming 3.0 firmware, users still seek jailbroken iPhone advantages -- and developers deliver
Consumer Electronics




