Software Vendor Says Partnership with SAP Led to Stolen Trade Secrets
It's the latest turn in a long-running dispute between Wellogix and SAP
Tue, November 22, 2011
IDG News Service — Former SAP partner Wellogix is accusing the vendor of stealing its trade secrets and swindling it out of lucrative software projects, according to a lawsuit Wellogix filed last week in U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Texas.
It's the latest twist in a feud between the companies that stems back to a 2005 marketing agreement Wellogix and SAP signed regarding Wellogix's electronic "purchase to pay," or P2P software, which helps oil and gas companies procure goods and services for well drilling projects.
Wellogix's software is "a highly valuable tool, capable of saving oil and gas operators and service companies millions of dollars per year, which leads to an increase in production of millions of dollars per year," the complaint states. "Wellogix was originally the only company capable of providing this type of software technology."
In 1999, BP America hired Accenture to help it "create a paperless (i.e. electronic) process in oil field services," it adds. "After a thorough review of over twenty vendors, including SAP, Accenture recommended Wellogix."
In January 2002, Wellogix and BP signed a software and services agreement, it adds. But Accenture then obtained confidential trade secrets from Wellogix and passed them along to SAP, according to the complaint.
SAP knew Wellogix's software had an "extremely high value," and around September 2002, the companies began discussing a potential partnership around P2P that would use "SAP software as the basic solution and Wellogix's P2P software for the complex services portion," the complaint adds.
While SAP already had an SRM (supplier relationship management module) that could handle some procurement tasks, it was inadequate for "complex services," according to the complaint. "Wellogix had a working version of this software, and SAP was aware that it worked in a large client environment such as BP."
In March 2005, the companies signed a partnership agreement that "explicitly recites that each party retains full ownership and control of its own intellectual property," and requires that confidential information be protected, the complaint states.
After the deal was signed, a number of SAP employees visited Wellogix's offices for a few days in order to "kick-off the NetWeaver Partner Agreement and perform [SAP's] due diligence on Wellogix for the purpose of either investment in or the acquisition of Wellogix," it adds. "During the workshop, employees of SAP went through Wellogix's P2P software code in person with Wellogix personnel disclosing parts of the code structure."
The companies later created joint marketing materials, and during presentations, SAP salesmen made clear the company was partnering with Wellogix because it didn't have a full range of P2P functionality, it adds.
