VMware and Microsoft are Missing the Boat on Private PaaS, Consultant Says
VMware's Cloud Foundry and Microsoft Azure are two of the leading platform as a service (PaaS) offerings from two cloud heavyweights, but one consultant says both companies are largely ignoring the private cloud market, creating a glaring hole for customers.
Fri, November 16, 2012
Network World — VMware's Cloud Foundry and Microsoft Azure are two of the leading platform as a service (PaaS) offerings from two cloud heavyweights, but one consultant says both companies are largely ignoring the private cloud market, creating a glaring hole for customers.
Slideshow: 10 Most Powerful PaaS Companies
John Treadway, a VP at Boston-area consultancy Cloud Technology Partners, says VMware and Microsoft are holding back the entire PaaS industry by not offering commercial support for on-premise installations of the their platforms.
"I spend a lot of time with large enterprises, and we're very big proponents of the PaaS opportunity," he says, but many customers are not willing to put resources in a public cloud, off their own premise, he says. Businesses and IT shops want to control these deployments behind their own firewall. "They want to run their own internal clouds," and VMware and Microsoft don't have the tools to do that for Cloud Foundry and Azure, he says.
AMAZON AND OBAMA: Amazon: Our cloud powered Obama's re-election campaign
GARTNER'S STATE OF CLOUD SECURITY: Outages are bigger risk than breaches
Part of this could be the immaturity of the overall PaaS market: Garnter recently reported that the $1.2 billion PaaS market is 8% the size of the $14.4 billion software as a service (SaaS) market in terms of IT spending. But Treadway says more customers would be open to using PaaS if companies like VMware and Microsoft offered private, on-premise versions of these services.
Cloud Foundry (CF) is VMware's open source PaaS environment, which has been used by a variety of service providers to build a PaaS deployment. VMware offers a hosted version of Cloud Foundry, but the company does not have a supported version that can be deployed on the customer's premise.
VMware says PaaS is on the roadmap. Company officials announced at VMworld earlier this year plans to implement the service, and in an emailed response to Treadway's claims, VMware officials said their plan is to roll out a private version of CF next year that's "optimized for vSphere and vCloud," the company's major cloud software systems. "We have had significant interest from customers since we launched Cloud Foundry as an open source project for a private cloud, product version of Cloud Foundry," VMware officials wrote.
Treadway is eager to see VMware's private CF, but he's worried the company is "dragging its feet." VMware insiders he's spoken to say they haven't seen the effort behind the keynote announcement. "I haven't seen any evidence of them really moving the ball on this," Treadway says. The company has released updated versions of its vSphere and GemFire Fusion applications, and has made some announcements around extending support for CF, but it has not yet released a private cloud version.