Wall Street Beat: Uncertainty Dampens Tech M&a, Pwc Says
Though cloud and software technology put pressure on companies to acquire IP, merger and acquisition activity may not increase this year
Fri, March 01, 2013
IDG News Service (New York Bureau) — Economic uncertainty tamped down the number and value of technology mergers and acquisitions in 2012 and this year may not look much different, according to PricewaterhouseCoopers (PwC).
Despite some big deals that closed in 2012 -- like Google's US$12.9 billion acquisition of Motorola Mobility and Cisco's $5.0 billion takeover of digital video technology company NDS Group -- M&A activity declined, according to a PwC report this week.
The uncertain economic climate curbed spending by both technology consumers and IT company acquirers, as overall IT spending growth ended up at an "anemic" 1.2 percent year-over-year increase for 2012, PwC said in its report, "PwC's US Technology M&A Insights."
Technology deal value for 2012 totalled $103.4 billion, a drop of 17 percent from 2011, according to PwC. The number of deals closed decreased 19 percent, as the year ended with 249 completed transactions, compared to 308 deals in 2011.
This year, the rush to cloud technology and the quickly evolving software market, in particular, will put competitive pressure on IT companies to make acquisitions, PwC said. In addition, tech companies are cash rich, so they have money to make acquisitions they feel are necessary. The top 25 U.S. tech companies had a total of $330 billion in cash by the end of 2012, PwC noted.
"The pressure of disruptive innovation has technology companies constantly seeking the next competitive differentiator, which requires investing in new talent, new technologies, R&D and M&A as a means to all three," wrote Rob Fisher, PwC's U.S. technology deals leader.
With hardware sales sagging, deals are likely to revolve around cloud-oriented and mobile technology, analytics and social-network-enabling software, PwC said.
Data from market researchers reinforces the idea that software will lead growth. Software, at $542 billion, will remain the largest category of global IT purchases in 2013, increasing 4.4 percent in dollar terms from 2012, according to Forrester Research. Computer hardware, at $416 billion, is the second-largest category, but will experience just 2.1 percent growth this year, Forrester said, after 1.2 percent growth in 2012.
On the whole, though, IT spending looks like it will be healthier this year. Global IT purchases will increase by 3.3 percent in 2013, in terms of U.S. dollars, to US$2.1 trillion, according to Forrester's 2013 forecast.
Nevertheless, economic uncertainty is not disappearing and will likely continue to make deals harder to value, placing at least one stumbling block in the way of M&A during the year.
"In the face of macroeconomic uncertainty, technology companies tend to conserve cash and exhibit less tolerance for earnings volatility," Fisher said in an email response to questions about the report. "These responses either dampen companies' appetites for acquisitions or requires them to spend far more time evaluating potential deals to avoid earnings dilution; thus reducing M&A activity."
Last year a large degree of uncertainty was caused by the U.S. presidential election. "With candidates presenting starkly different visions for American economic policy, technology companies spent ten months of the year attempting to divine which of the many pundits might be right in their predictions of the outcome and its knock-on effects to the economy," PwC said.
The fiscal cliff also caused anxiety that dampened spending. The fiscal cliff, a series of government spending cuts and tax hikes set to kick in by Jan. 1 if a budget compromise was not reached, was averted by an 11th-hour compromise on taxes. The sovereign debt crisis in Europe, with Greece and Spain debt levels skyrocketing, caused concerns that the euro zone would not survive, though ultimately the European Central bank stepped in with financing plans that quelled anxiety.
But the fiscal cliff compromise in the U.S. did not include a deal on spending, and Friday the so-called "sequestration" of government funds -- amounting to $85 billion in automatic across-the-board spending cuts -- started to kick in. In addition, recession is forecast for several E.U. countries this year.
The U.S. Department of Commerce on Thursday reported that gross domestic production in the fourth quarter increased at an annual rate of 0.1 percent -- better than the 0.1 percent decrease forecast by some analysts but nowhere near the rate needed to bring unemployment down significantly.
Meanwhile, the Nasdaq Computer Index edged slightly higher Friday in afternoon trading as major U.S. exchanges and indices rose. On the Nasdaq, Apple shares declined by $8.20 to $433.20, but that drop was offset by gains in shares of Oracle, Microsoft, Google, Intel and Dell. On the New York Stock Exchange, Hewlett-Packard and IBM shares were trading up for the day.
The Dow Jones Industrial Average, the Standard and Poor's 500 index and the Nasdaq all closed out February higher for the month. However, markets have had a roller-coaster week as the March 1 deadline neared for the start of the government budget sequestration. Economic uncertainty is unlikely to end soon.
"As companies continue to focus on core businesses, digest strategic acquisitions of the last decade, and work to scale these already acquired offerings," the PwC report concludes, "we may see a similarly subdued environment in 2013."