by CIO Staff

HP’s Hurd, Dunn Grilled by Lawmakers

Sep 29, 20066 mins

gavel justice judicial system law lawyer judge bureaucracy governance compliance
Credit: Getty Images

Former Hewlett-Packard (HP) Chairwoman Patricia Dunn was assured that methods used by investigators to find the source of leaks from the company’s board of directors were legal, she told a U.S. Congress subcommittee Thursday.

Dunn also told lawmakers she believed any investigative techniques used during the 2006 portion of the investigation had to be approved by HP President and Chief Executive Officer Mark Hurd.

HP CEO Mark Hurd
HP CEO Mark Hurd

Hurd told lawmakers he did not know the methods of an internal HP team investigating the board leaks. He did not read a March report from the team describing its use of pretexting, a practice in which someone poses as a customer in order to gain access to personal records such as telephone logs.

“I pick my spots when I dive for details,” he said. “This [investigation] was not a priority for me.”

Dunn trusted HP employees and lawyers who told her the investigation complied with HP’s high standards of conduct, she told the Oversight and Investigations Subcommittee of the House Energy and Commerce Committee. HP has disclosed that the year-old investigation included pretexting to gain the personal records of reporters, HP board members and employees.

When questions about the investigative techniques surfaced recently, Dunn passed concerns about the investigation’s techniques to Hurd, she said. Before then, HP’s internal lawyers assured her the investigative techniques were being done “legally and properly,” she said.

Former HP Chairman Patricia Dunn
Patricia Dunn

“I deeply regret that so many people, including myself, were let down” by trusted HP advisers, she said.

Dunn, who was forced to resign Sept. 21, told lawmakers she authorized the investigation but did not oversee its operation. That task fell to the HP legal team, and two of its members declined to testify. “At no time in the investigation did I authorize its methods,” Dunn said. “I asked this to be done in the HP standard way.”

But lawmakers pointed to three documents, including the handwritten notes of former HP general counsel Ann Baskins, saying Dunn was told of pretexting methods as early as June 2005. Dunn said she was unaware that investigators were misrepresenting themselves in order to get personal records until July of this year.

Dunn said she doesn’t remember the June 2005 conversation referenced in Baskins’ note. “I had no reason to think anything illegal was going on,” she said. “I had batteries of experts telling me that wasn’t the case.”

Rep. Cliff Stearns, a Florida Republican, asked Dunn if she should take any blame for the questionable investigative methods. “If I knew then what I know now, I would have done things differently,” she said.

Stearns asked again if she had any culpability. “I do not accept personal responsibility for what happened,” Dunn answered.

With HP officials telling her the investigation methods were legal, Dunn said she had no ethical concerns, she said. “I believed these [investigations] may be in fact quite common, not just at Hewlett-Packard, but at companies across the country,” she said.

HP security investigator Fred Adler said he was not aware of any other times when HP has used pretexting, but he believes HP has used e-mail tracing technology a “dozen to two dozen” times for internal investigation in the three years he’s worked there.

Some subcommittee members said Congress needs to pass a new law making it clear that pretexting is illegal. But several lawmakers suggested the practice is already illegal under a handful of federal laws as well as a California law prohibiting the use of false information to get customer information from utilities.

Members of the subcommittee asked how HP, long recognized as a corporate leader in protecting consumer privacy, could embrace questionable legal practices such as pretexting.

“It’s pretending to be someone you’re not, to get something you probably shouldn’t have, to use in a way that’s probably wrong,” said Rep. Joe Barton, chairman of the Energy and Commerce Committee.

Barton asked Dunn if she’d give him her phone records if he just called and asked for them without a subpoena.

“In your position, I would give you my phone records,” Dunn said.

“Well, praise the Lord,” Barton said to laughter in the audience. “I wouldn’t give you mine.”

Former HP General Counsel, Senior Vice President and Secretary Ann Baskins
Ann Baskins

Baskins, who resigned earlier Thursday as HP’s senior vice president and general counsel, and Kevin Hunsaker, the company’s senior legal counsel, both asserted their rights not to testify under the Fifth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution during the hearing.

Eight outside investigators who allegedly worked with HP to identify the board leaks declined to testify.

HP also considered putting spyware on reporters’ computers, digging through trash, and putting spies into the newsrooms of news organizations reporting board details, subcommittee members said.

The actions taken by HP were “not the act of one rogue employee,” said Rep. Jay Inslee, a Democrat from Washington state, indicating that at least some of the politicians might not accept the characterization of the events at HP that its chief is set to offer before the subcommittee. In a written version of his testimony made available earlier, President and Chief Executive Officer Mark Hurd called the scandal the result of a “rogue investigation.”

Inslee and Rep. Marsha Blackburn of Tennessee have co-authored legislation that would prohibit the obtaining of customer information from telecommunications carriers by false pretenses, and the sale or disclosure of such records obtained by false pretenses. Subcommittee Democrats questioned why the House hasn’t voted on the bill, which the committee approved unanimously in early May.

In her opening remarks, Blackburn, a Republican, called pretexting a purposeful effort to deceive and defraud in order to get information one is not entitled to have. “How prevalent is it in the corporate boardroom?” she asked.

Criminalization of pretexting needs to extend to all forms of telecommunications, said Rep. Tammy Baldwin, a Democrat from Wisconsin, adding that legislation must address records ranging from conventional telecom through mobile and Internet telephony. She called for a “comprehensive legislative approach” to cover all sectors where pretexting could occur.

-Grant Gross, IDG News Service (Washington Bureau)

Keep checking in at our HP Spying Scandal page for more coverage of this unfolding story.

Check out our CIO News Alerts and Tech Informer pages for more updated news coverage.