Why Overhearing One Side of Cell Phone Calls Is Bad for You
A new study shows that being forced to listen to one half of a person's cell phone conversation is far more distracting than overhearing two people talk.
By Bill Snyder
Listening to one-side of a cell phone conversation as some thoughtless person yaks on is really annoying. That’s no news. But a just-published study out of the University of San Diego shows that when you’re subjected to other people’s conversation on their cell phones you’ll be much more distracted than you thought, and much more distracted than if you had listened to a conversation by two people in the same room or elevator or train.
The researchers found that those one-side conversations lower the ability to concentrate and make the unwilling participants quite irritated. It also appears one-sided conversations stick in the brains of unwilling listeners. The test subjects in the study remembered more of the one-side conversations than they did when listening to two-sided conversations.
The subjects were college students who were asked to complete anagrams while a nearby researcher talked on a cell phone. They didn’t know that the conversations were actually part of the experiment; they thought the study was examining the relationship between anagrams and reading comprehension. The few students who figured out what was really going on, were dropped from the study.
Although it’s obvious that listening to a stranger’s conversation is annoying, the answer to why a one-sided conversation is so distracting is much less intuitive. After all, the world is full of other people talking to each other, so what’s the difference?
Researchers say that we tend to focus on new or unexpected things or events. “When you’re listening to one half of a conversation, every new utterance is a surprise, so you’re forced to constantly predict what’s going to happen next,” Lauren Emberson, a researcher at the University of Rochester, told the New York Times.
With cell phone use an ever-present fact, scientists are studying it more frequently, and finding evidence of its annoying and sometimes dangerous effects.
You’ve probably noticed how loud people speak on their cell phones. But you might be wrong. In a 2004 study, 64 commuters were exposed to the same conversation at different volume levels, half as a cellphone call and half as a face-to-face talk. On average, the commuters thought the mobile phone talkers were louder, even when they were not.
Other research has shown that your chances of being in an accident when driving while talking on a cell phone, even if you’re in the hands-free mode, are as high as if you had been drinking, according to data cited in the University of San Diego study.
Pedestrians talking on cell phones while crossing the street are courting danger as well. One study found that cell phone talkers were so distracted that they didn’t even see a clown riding on a unicycle as they crossed. Now that’s distracted.
There’s another issues that studies don’t speak to, and that’s politeness. It’s simply rude to interrupt someone else’s quiet commute, or lunch, or even their time trapped in a line to buy a ticket, with your conversation.